An investment return needs a cash basis, a valuation date and a clear distinction between amounts received and amounts still held. A large ending balance can reflect new contributions rather than investment profit.

Reconcile the investor's money

Start with all contributed outflows. Add net profit, then check that the result equals cash received plus remaining value. Withdrawals and distributions leave the investment; reinvested dividends and retained rental cash remain inside it. Treating the same cash as both received and remaining overstates profit.

Choose observed results or future assumptions

Historical mode starts from an entered observed endpoint. Its intermediate line is an illustration, not a reconstructed price series. Future mode applies the selected return, fees and cash schedule. The result is a scenario; a constant assumed rate cannot describe every real market path.

Respect the timing of each contribution

A deposit at the end of a month does not earn that month's return. An annual deposit is made at its anniversary, not spread across the preceding months. Dated cash flows use actual days / 365. These distinctions affect annualized return, target timing, tables and exports even when total contributions match.

Separate the calculation from a decision

Return percentages alone do not measure liquidity, risk or retirement affordability. Flat tax and property-tax settings are simplified illustrations rather than filing calculations. Read each assumption and keep unsupported annualized measures unavailable. Compare cash flows and horizons explicitly instead of treating a higher ending value as a universal investment ranking.