The Right Depth Makes a Difference
Too thin a layer (under 2 inches) allows weeds to push through and sunlight to reach the soil. Too thick (over 4 inches) can create a matted barrier that repels water and starves roots of oxygen. The sweet spot is 2-3 inches for most garden beds and 3-4 inches for pathways and perennial borders.
When to Refresh Your Mulch
Most organic mulches decompose and thin out within 1-2 years. Refresh in early spring after the last frost. Remove any matted or moldy mulch before adding a fresh layer. If the existing mulch is still in good condition, add only enough to bring the total depth back to 3 inches rather than piling new mulch on top.